|
Write with your eyes like
painters,
with your ears like musicians,
with your feet like dancers. You are
the truthsayer with quill and torch.
Write with your tongues on fire.
-- Gloria Anzaldua
We cannot work in isolation,
or in fear of other voices.
--Adrienne Rich
I have been in prison five
years. I'm doing twenty five years. I like poetry because I tell
on myself... and it does something for me as a man.
--Raymond Webster
Many of us, rebels, political
prisoners, prisoners of conscience, anarchs, social prisoners
politicized by their slip into the abyss, bear witness to the
power of change...
Change -- to strengthen; to build; to become clearer in purpose;
to grow more human.
--Mumia Abu-Jamal
Poetry is not a luxury. It
is a vital necessity of our existence. It forms the quality of
the light within which we predicate our hopes and dreams toward
survival and change, first made into language, then into idea,
then into more tangible action. Poetry is the way we help give
name to the nameless so it can be thought.
-- Audre Lorde
The deepest secret in our
heart of hearts
is that we are writing because we love the world.
--Natalie Goldberg
Words Have Eyes That See
--Michelle Gibbs
COURSE SYLLABUS
Introduction to Creative Writing
HCOM 330 Spring 1999 (formerly 331B)
Fulfills HCOM MLO 8 in Creative Writing and Social Action
Professor: Debra Busman
Office: Building 6; Room 110
Phone: Phone: 582-4475
E-mail: E-mail: debra_busman@monterey.edu
Office Hours:
Tues./Thurs. 9-10 a.m.; Thurs. 1-2 p.m.
nd by appointment
Course Description:
This is an introductory creative writing course for women and
men in which you, as writers, will begin to "break silence"
and lend your voices to the growing body of writers who are speaking
out against social injustice, refusing to have their lived experiences
rendered invisible, driven underground, marginalized. As writers,
you will place the experiences of your own lives at the center
of your creative inquiry and expression. Individually and together,
we will explore the complex interweavings of ethnicity, class
and gender, and the ways they inform our understanding of today's
social, economic, political, cultural and sexual issues.
In this class, you will form a community of writers and learn
how to be compassionate and critically engaged readers for one
another's work. You will read an extensive array of poetry, fiction
and non-fiction by writers from around the country, looking at
the multitude of ways in which they use writing as an "act
of resistance." You will learn to engage texts in a "writerly"
rather than "readerly" manner, focusing on the tools
of craft a writer employs -- simile, metaphor, dialogue, setting,
voice, character development, etc. And, you will write. A lot.
You will produce works of poetry, fiction and creative non-fiction
(autobiography, memoir, life-story), and you will take your words
beyond the page, "take it to the streets," connecting
to a diverse audience, expanding your community of readers.
Course Requirements:
Workshop participation: In small and large groups,
you will workshop one another's writing, giving respectful attention
and feedback to each other's work. Writing (with enough copies
for everyone in the workshop group) will be turned in the class
period before the workshop is to take place, allowing time for
everyone to give each piece a careful reading and provide supportive
written comments to be handed back to the writer.
Reading and class discussion: You are expected to have
completed all course readings before class and be prepared to
engage in lively and thoughtful discussion. Discussion will not
so much focus on traditional "literary criticism,"
but rather on how you are personally impacted by the work; how
(and if) the work functions as a tool for social protest and
change; what you think the writers have achieved in their writing;
and how did they do it -- what stylistic or "craft"
tools did they employ; and how can we learn to use these techniques
in our own writing?
Writing, writing, writing: Throughout the semester,
you will be building a body of original creative writings through
in-class exercises, experimental freewrites and journaling, take-home
assignments, and the process of workshopping and revising your
pieces. You will produce a portfolio of your writings to be turned
in at the end of the semester. As writers, you will also practice
literally "giving voice" to your work, reading out
loud to yourself and others, experiencing the vibrancy, rhythm
and power of the spoken word.
Group production and involvement: At the end of the
semester, you will, as a community of writers, present a public
reading of your finest (and/or favorite) work this semester.
You will also create a collaborative E-Zine on the Web, incorporating
writings and visuals from class.
Required Texts:
- No More Masks: An Anthology of Twentieth Century American
Women Poets, ed. Florence Howe, N.Y: Harper, 1993
- Bearing Witness: Selections from African-American Autobiography
in the Twentieth Century, ed. Henry Louis Gates, Jr., Pantheon,
1991
- Before Columbus Foundation Fiction Anthology: 1980-1990,
eds. Ishmael Reed, Kathryn Trueblood and Shawn Wong, Norton,
1992
- Sudden Fiction, eds Robert Shapard and James Thomas,
Salt Lake City: Peregrine Smith, 1986
Text On Reserve at the Library:
- Against Forgetting: Twentieth Century Poetry of Witness,
ed. Carolyn Forche, Norton, 1993
- Hauling Up the Morning: Writings and Art by Political
Prisoners & Prisoners of War in the U.S., ds. Tim Blunk,
Raymond Luc Levasseur, The Red Sea Press, 1990
- What is Found There: Notebooks on Poetry and Politics,
Adrienne Rich, Norton, 1994
Attendance and Other Guidlines:
The format of this class is group workshop. Through this process,
you will learn to critique your own and others' writing. For
the class session in which your writing is workshopped, bring
copies for everyone (large workshop: 18 copies; small group workshop:
4 copies). Each writer in the workshop will respond with oral
and written comments about your writing. You will also receive
comments from me. All writing should be typed, double-spaced.
Your ideas are central to this course and it is important
that you come to class prepared to share them. Attendance in
every sense of the word is required. The experiential form of
this class requires attendance, participation, and close, respectful
attention to one another's work. Please arrange your schedule
so that you do not miss class.
Always come to class with writing paper and pens/pencils.
We will be doing a lot of in-class writing exercises throughout
the semester.
Major Learning Outcome:
This class fulfills the HCOM MLO in Creative Writing and Social
Action, MLO 8
MLO 8: CREATIVE WRITING AND SOCIAL ACTION MLO
Acquiring basic competency in creative writing. Applying this
skill to the production and presentation of an art project that
actively responds to a public issue. Developing the skills to
sustain the creative process throughout a given project, taking
it to completion.
What does this mean? The emphasis here is on moving the student
to produce creative writing that is aware of its context in and
impact on the larger community. The student witnesses her/his
experience, communicates to a diverse audience, and links with
the interests and needs of that audience. This MLO also develops
the student's awareness of what it takes to make creative writing
happen. Social action writing/art is a form of critical inquiry;
it is writing that breaks silence, that witnesses, and through
that witnessing, transforms lives.
Note: Many of the MLOs in Human Communication
focus on developing the student's analytical skill. The creative
writing and social action MLO develops the student's creative
skill, as well as her/his ability to respond to a public issue.
ASSESSMENT: See end of syllabus for criteria and standards
for assessment.
GRADE: (Three missed sessions can affect grade). Midterm
oral grade available upon request.
Writing: 80%
Group Production Involvement and Classroom Participation: 20%
**Students wishing Credit-No Credit should inform me in writing
by Thursday, Feb. 4, 1999.
COURSE LEARNING OUTCOMES and ASSIGNMENTS:
Students who successfully complete "Introduction to Creative
Writing" will be able to demonstrate skills and knowledge
of the craft of creative writing, social action as it applies
to creative writing, the writing process, interdisciplinary art,
presentation and distribution of original writing, and group
production and involvement.
1. Craft:
- Understand the basic elements of craft as they apply to the
genres of creative non-fiction, poetry, and the short story.
- Learn the process of revision.
- Write, at an introductory undergraduate level, creative non-fiction
(life story, memoir) poetry, and short story.
- Develop a sense of what constitutes strong writing, by critiquing
your own and others' work.
- Produce a portfolio of original creative writings.
Assignments:
- Write and re-write one autobiography/life-story, one poem,
one short story, and one response to a social issue (any genre)
- Read assigned poetry and short stories (in texts and handouts)
of established poets and writers, and actively discuss craft.
- Participate actively and thoughtfully in the workshop process:
reading with attention and offering considered constructive written
and oral comments.
- Make appointments with instructor, as needed, to discuss
writing.
Documentation of craft:
Hand in a portfolio of writings: keep copies (in a folder) of
the writing you bring to class for workshop, along with my comments.
At the end of the semester, all drafts and final revisions will
be handed in for a letter grade.
2. Social Action Writing:
- Evaluate through literature, the stereotypes and conventions
of diverse cultures.
- Investigate the ways in which writers, by witnessing their
worlds, have redefined those stereotypes and conventions.
- Understand the emancipatory and culture-creating properties
of the writing act in the context of its social, cultural, historical
or political background.
Assignments:
Read poetry, creative non-fiction, and short stories in texts,
as assigned.
Actively participate in class discussions.
Documentation:
Oral discussion of the social, cultural, historical and political
contexts out of which the social action writing emerges.
3. Writing Process:
- Learn what roadblocks silence you in the writing process
and remove them.
- Recognize, implement, and sustain your creative writing process.
- Learn what you want to write about and write it, in poetry,
short story, creative non-fiction.
- Discover and write in your "authentic voice" --
"What you hear when no one is listening." (Adrienne
Rich)
Assignments:
- Read essays, as assigned
- Actively participate in class discussions.
- Make appointment and discuss with instructor.
- Apply to your own writing.
Documentation:
Keep a journal of your writing process throughout the semester.
This is for your eyes only.After portfolio is completed at the
end of the semester, write and hand in an analysis of your writing
process, and reflect on what you've learned.
4. Interdisciplinarity:
Understand interdisciplinarity as enhancement of your
writings.
Assignment and Documentation:
Produce an original visual representation of your writings.
5. Presentation and Distribution, in the context of
Group Production and Involvement:
- Develop presentation and distribution skills.
- Learn and practice sensitivity, thoughtfulness, and respect
for group partners.
- Learn to produce, collaboratively.
Assignment and Documentation:
- Produce a collaborative E-Zine on Web, incorporating writings
and visuals from class.
- Present your original writing and art to a diverse public
audience, in an end-of-semester public reading.
Major Due Dates:
February 4: Take-home writing assignment
February 16: Turn in Assignment #1 -- Creative Non-Fiction
(make copies for everybody in your workshop group)
March 9: Turn in Assignment #2 -- Poem
(make copies for everybody in your workshop group)
April 6: Turn in Assignment #3 -- Short Story
(make copies for everybody in your workshop group)
April 22: Turn in Assignment #4 -- Social Action/any genre
(make copies for everybody in your workshop group)
May 4: Turn in writing and visuals for E-Zine
May 6: Public Presentation
May 11: Portfolios due
May 13: E-Zine up and running
Analysis of writing process due
Course Outline:
Week 1
Thursday, Jan. 28 -- Breaking Silence, Bearing Witness
Introductions
Discuss syllabus, MLO
Week 2
Tuesday, Feb. 2 -- The Politics of Voice
Discuss readings:
Henry Louis Gates, "Introduction: On Bearing Witness,"
from Bearing Witness
Gloria Anzaldua, "Speaking in Tongues: A Letter to 3rd World
Women Writers" (handout)
bell hooks, "Talking Back" (handout)
Thursday, Feb. 4 -- The Borderlands -- "Where I Come From
Is Like This"
Voices
Discuss readings:
Richard Wright, "The Ethics of Living Jim Crow: An Autobiographical
Sketch," Bearing Witness
Cherrie Moraga, "La Guera" (handout)
Toshio Mori, "Lil' Yokohama," Before Columbus Fiction
Anthology
Mab Segrest, "Memoir of a Race Traitor" (handout)
Writing Exercise
Week 3
Tuesday, Feb. 9 -- Creative Non-Fiction
Turn in 1-2 page writing assignment
Discuss readings:
Junot Diaz, "Drown"
Esmerelda Santiago, from When I was Puerto Rican
Audre Lorde, "How I Became a Poet," pp. 228-231 in
Bearing Witness
Thursday, Feb. 11 -- Writing Race, Writing Gender
Voices
Mary Crow Dog, from Lakota Woman
Claude Brown, from Manchild in the Promised Land, in Bearing
Witness
Jamaica Kincaid, "Girl"
Lillian Smith, "Killers of the Dream"
Writing exercise
Week 4
Tuesday, Feb. 16 -- Writing Our Lives
Turn in Assignment #1 -- 18 copies for large workshop; 4 copies
for small workshop
Workshop agreements
Large group workshop
Thursday, Feb. 18 -- Workshop
Small group workshop
Give writers back copies of their pieces with your comments
Week 5
Tuesday, Feb. 23 -- "Poetry is Not a Luxury"
Turn in revised Assignment #1
Begin section on Poetry
Thursday, Feb. 25 -- The Personal is Political: Learning Sex/
Learning Gender
Voices
Discuss readings:
Cherrie Moraga, "For the Color of My Mother" nmm p445
Sharon Olds, "The Girl," "First Sex" nmm
p346-8
Tess Gallagher, "I Stop Writing the Poem," nmm p354
Diane Wakoski, "The Girls," nmm 289
E. Ethelbert Miller, "She is flat on her back"
Peter Spiro, "He Wanted to Show Me"
Joseph Duemer, "Burn Victim,"
Frank Stewart, "The Dance"
Week 6
Tuesday, March 2 -- Poems of Anger, Poems of Love
Discuss readings:
Marge Piercy, "A Just Anger"
June Jordan, "Case in Point," "Poem About My Rights"
nmm p266-8
Muriel Rukeyser, "This Morning"
Nikki Giovanni, "Adulthood"
Tim Blunk, "liberated territory"
Mumia Abu-Jamal, "Sister Mona Africa"
Jamal Josephs, "No Distance at All"
Katya Komisaruk, "They Are Searching"
E. Ethelbert Miller, "Untitled (where are the love poems
for dictators)"
Writing exercise
Thursday, March 4 -- Against Forgetting
Voices
Discuss readings
Joy Harjo, "Remember"
Susan Griffin, "I Like to Think About Harriet Tubman"
nmm p360
Richard Williams, "Mairead, St. Patrick's Day, 1988"
Janice Mirikitani, "In Remembrance"
Judy Clark, "Sister Says"
John Balaban, "For the Missing in Action"
Etheridge Knight, "The Idea of Ancestry"
Jimmy Santiago Baca, "How We Carry Ourselves"
Otto Rene Castillo, "Apolitical Intellectuals"
Week 7
Tuesday, March 9 -- Workshop
Turn in Assignment #2 (18 copies for large group; 4 copies for
small group)
Large group workshop
Thursday, March 11 -- Workshop
Small group workshop
Hand back poems with written comments to writers
Week 8
Tuesday, March 16 -- The Short Story
Begin section on the short story
Discuss readings:
Langston Hughes, "Thank You, Ma'm" sf
Thursday, March 18 -- Crafting Our Lives
Voices
Readings:
Tobias Wolff, "Say Yes" sf
Elizabeth Talent, "No One's A Mystery" sf
Paul Milenski, "Tickits" sf
John Cheever, "Reunion" sf
John Updike, "The Widow"
Begin working on your short stories
Week 9
SPRING BREAK!!!
Week 10
Tuesday, March 30 -- Crafting Our Lives
Readings:
Leslie Marmon Silko, excerpts from Ceremony bc
Hisaye Yamamoto, "Seventeen Syllables;" Dorothy Allison,
"River of Names"
Tim O'Brien, "The Things They Carried;" Leslie Marmon
Silko, "Tony's Story"
Writing Exercise
Thursday, April 1
Voices
Readings:
Toni Cade Bambara, "The Lesson"
Sandra Cisneros, excerpts from The House on Mango Street bc
Week 11
Tuesday, April 6 -- Workshop
Turn in short story for workshop (18 copies for large; 4 copies
for small)
Thursday, April 8 -- Workshop
Small group workshop
Return stories with written comments
Week 12
Tuesday, April 13 -- Social Action Writing: Passion and Protest
Begin section of Social Action Writing
Thursday, April 15 -- Writing Our Rage
Discuss readings:
Alice Walker, "Nobody Was Supposed to Survive": The
MOVE Massacre
Wadiyah Jamal, "A Living Nightmare"
Hakim Al-Jamil, "who killed mcduffie? a definitive question"
Tim Blunk, "for comrades who ask, 'what is to be done?'
during this particular historical conjuncture, a (partial) list
of practical things to do"
Janice Mirikitani, "Breaking Silence"
Assata Shakur, "No One Can Stop the Rain"
Writing Assignment
Week 13
Tuesday, April 20 -- Choose Your Issue
Discuss ideas for final assignment: response (any genre) to a
social issue
Share readings: (bring in poems, stories, visual art that speak
to your issue)
Thursday, April 22 -- Large workshop
Turn in Assignment #4 (18 copies for large workshop, 4 copies
for small groups)
Large workshop
Discuss and plan web page
Week 14
Tuesday, April 27 -- Workshop
Small group workshop
Return pieces with written comments
Thursday, April 29 -- The Joys of Revision
Continue work on E-Zine
Workshop revised pieces for E-Zine and/or portfolio
Week 15
Tuesday, May 4
Turn in writing and visual collaboration for E-Zine on Web
Workshop revised pieces
Prepare for Public Presentation
Thursday, May 6
Workshop revised pieces for portfolio
Public Presentation
Week 16
Tuesday, May 11
Portfolio due
Thursday, May 13
Turn in written analysis of your creative process
E-Zine up and running
Relax, reflect and celebrate
Assessment:
MLO 8: CREATIVE WRITING AND SOCIAL ACTION MLO
Acquiring basic competency in creative writing. Applying this
skill to the production and presentation of an art project that
actively responds to a public issue. Developing the skills to
sustain the creative process throughout a given project, taking
it to completion.
What does this mean:
The emphasis here is on moving the student to produce creative
writing that is aware of its context in and impact on the larger
community. The student witnesses her/his experience, communicates
to a diverse audience, and links with the interests and needs
of that audience. This MLO also develops the student's awareness
of what it takes to make creative writing happen. Social action
writing/art is a form of critical inquiry; it is writing that
breaks silences, that witnesses, and through that witnessing,
transforms lives.
Note: Many of the MLOs in Human Communication
focus on developing the student's analytical skill. The creative
writing and social action MLO develops the student's creative
skill, as well as her/his ability to respond to a public issue.
Criteria for Assessment:
- Is the portfolio original?
- Does the portfolio demonstrate basic competency in creative
writing?
- Does the portfolio demonstrate the student's ability to produce
imagery and communicate ideas and intent?
- Does the portfolio address the social, cultural, historical
or political contexts out of which the social action art emerges?
- Does the portfolio represent an informed and ethical reflection
of a significant social issue?
- Has the student demonstrated the ability to present writing
to a diverse audience and engage with the interests and needs
of that audience?
- In a post-production analysis, has the student demonstrated
the ability to recognize and sustain her/his own creative process
throughout the project?
See below for standards, pages 10-12.
MLO 8: Creative Writing and Social Action Assessment Standards
(A level of 3 is necessary to fulfill the built-in assessment).
Fiction
5 . Exemplary.
The short story meets all of the criteria stated above.
The work establishes a resonant dramatic situation and an engaging
plot. Characters are fully developed. The point of view is cleverly
chosen to relate the story. Setting is described to evoke a strong
sense of place. The story employs an excellent use of sensory
details and concrete language to develop plot and characters.
It excludes unnecessary details and inconsistencies. It effectively
uses a range of strategies such as dialogue, dramatic tension,
rhythm, and figurative language. The story addresses, excellently,
the social, cultural, historical or political contexts out of
which the social action art emerges. It demonstrates, profoundly,
an informed and ethical reflection of a significant social issue.
The story has been presented very effectively to a diverse audience
and profoundly engaged with the interests and needs of that audience.
Errors in spelling, punctuation,
mechanics, and usage are rare.
4 . Very Good.
The short story meets all of the criteria stated above.
The work establishes a clear dramatic situation and an engaging
plot. Characters are developed fairly completely. The point of
view is cleverly chosen to relate the story, but may be inconsistent
at times. Setting is generally described to evoke an adequate
sense of place. The story employs some sensory details and some
concrete language. Plot and characters need some development.
Few unrelated details and inconsistencies exist. Dialogue, dramatic
tension, rhythm, figurative language are adequately employed.
The story addresses, fairly completely, the social, cultural,
historical or political contexts out of which the social action
art emerges. It adequately demonstrates an informed and ethical
reflection of a significant social issue. The story has been
presented story fairly well to a diverse audience and engaged
adequately with the interests and needs of that audience. Errors
in spelling, punctuation, mechanics, and usage do not impede
understanding.
3 . Satisfactory.
The short story meets most of the criteria above.
A basic dramatic situation and plot exists in the work. Characters,
setting, and point of view chosen to relate the story are discernible.
Sensory details and concrete language are adequately used. Several
unnecessary details and inconsistencies are present. Dialogue,
dramatic tension, rhythm, and figurative language need further
crafting. The story is moving toward addressing the social, cultural,
historical or political contexts out of which the social action
art emerges. Some evidence exists of an informed and ethical
reflection of the significant social issue. The story has been
presented to a diverse audience. Errors in spelling, punctuation,
mechanics, and usage do not impede understanding.
2. Needs Improvement.
The short story meets some of the criteria stated above. The
work may need a clear dramatic situation and an engaging plot.
Characters need development . The point of view chosen to relate
the story requires consistency. Setting requires more description.
An awareness of sensory details and concrete language is necessary,
and plot and characters need development. Dialogue, dramatic
tension, rhythm, and figurative language may need work. The story
may need to address the social, cultural, historical or political
contexts out of which the social action art emerges. Work needs
to demonstrate a more informed and ethical reflection of the
significant social issue. The story may need to be presented
to a diverse audience. Errors in spelling, punctuation, mechanics,
and usage impedes understanding.
1. Needs Considerable Improvement.
The short story meets a few of the criteria stated above. The
dramatic situation, characters, plot, setting and point of view
need development. Dialogue, dramatic tension, rhythm, and figurative
language need extensive work. The story needs to address the
social, cultural, historical or political contexts out of which
the social action art emerges The work needs to demonstrate a
more informed and ethical reflection of the significant social
issue. The story needs to be presented to a diverse audience.
Errors in spelling, punctuation, mechanics, and usage impedes
understanding.
Poetry
5 . Exemplary.
The poem meets all of the criteria stated above. The work establishes
a resonant moment or illumination. The poem employs utmost precision
and vividness in the use of language, producing density and intensity
of expression. It achieves maximum impact with a minimal number
of words. The poem uses specific, strong, representative details,
and avoids abstractions and generalities. Excellent use of figurative
language. The rhythm is compelling. There is evocative use of
the senses, effective linebreaks, and an authentic voice. The
poem addresses, excellently, the social, cultural, historical
or political contexts out of which the social action art emerges.
The poem demonstrates, profoundly, an informed and ethical reflection
of a significant social issue. The poem has been presented to
a diverse audience and profoundly engaged with the interests
and needs of that audience. Errors in spelling, punctuation,
mechanics, and usage are rare.
4 . Very Good.
The poem meets all of the criteria stated above. The work establishes
a clear moment or illumination. The poem employs some precision
and vividness in the use of language, producing some density
and intensity of expression. It achieves an adequate impact,
despite its need, occasionally, for tightening the number of
words. The poem uses representative details, and occasional abstractions
and generalities. Some use of figurative language. The rhythm
is apparent. The senses, voice, linebreaks are adequately employed.
The poem addresses, fairly completely, the social, cultural,
historical or political contexts out of which the social action
art emerges. It demonstrates, fairly well, an informed and ethical
reflection of a significant social issue. The poem has been presentedto
a diverse audience and engaged adequately with the interests
and needs of that audience. Errors in spelling, punctuation,
mechanics, and usage do not impede understanding.
3 . Satisfactory.
The poem meets most of the criteria stated above. The work demonstrates
a basic moment or illumination. Representative details, senses,
rhythm chosen to relate the poem are discernible. Occasional
use of figurative language. Adequate linebreaks. Voice is apparent.
Density and intensity of expression need further development.
Several unnecessary details are present or more detail required.
Tends toward abstractions and generalities. The poem is moving
toward the social, cultural, historical or political contexts
out of which the social action art emerges. Some evidence exists
of an informed and ethical reflection of the significant social
issue. The poem has been presented to a diverse audience. Errors
in spelling, punctuation, mechanics, and usage do not impede
understanding.
2. Needs Improvement
The poem meets some of the criteria stated above. The work may
need a clearer moment or illumination. The representative details,
senses, rhythm may require more work. The poem needs to demonstrate
a greater use of figurative language. Linebreaks and voice may
need work. Density and intensity of expression may need extensive
development. Attention to detail may require more work. The work
primarily tends toward abstractions and generalities. The poem
may need to demonstrate the social, cultural, historical or political
contexts out of which the social action art emerges. It may need
to demonstrate a more informed and ethical reflection of the
significant social issue. The poem may need to be presented to
a diverse audience. Errors in spelling, punctuation, mechanics,
and usage impede understanding.
1. Needs Considerable Improvement.
The poem meets a few of the criteria stated above The work needs
a more clear moment or illumination. Representative details,
senses, rhythm, figurative language, linebreaks, and voice may
not be discernible. Attention to detail requires work. The work
primarily tends toward abstractions and generalities. The poem
needs to demonstrate the social, cultural, historical or political
contexts out of which the social action art emerges. The work
needs to demonstrate a more informed and ethical reflection of
the significant social issue. The poem needs to be presented
to a diverse audience. Errors in spelling, punctuation, mechanics,
and usage impede understanding.
Creative Non-Fiction (Narrative, Life-Story,
Personal Essay):
5 . Exemplary.
The creative non-fiction writing meets all of the criteria stated
above. The work establishes a resonant dramatic situation and
an engaging narrative, around a lived experience. Characters
are fully developed. Extensive research has been done and facts
are accurate. The voice is authentic. The point of view is cleverly
chosen to relate the narrative. Setting is described to evoke
a strong sense of place. The story employs an excellent use of
sensory details and concrete language to develop narrative and
characters. It excludes unnecessary details and inconsistencies.
It effectively uses a range of strategies such as dialogue, dramatic
tension, rhythm, and figurative language. The writing addresses,
excellently, the social, cultural, historical or political contexts
out of which the social action art emerges. It demonstrates,
profoundly, an informed and ethical reflection of a significant
social issue. The work has been presented to a diverse audience
and engaged with the interests and needs of that audience. Errors
in spelling, punctuation, mechanics, and usage are rare.
4 .Very Good.
The creative non-fiction writing meets all of the criteria stated
above. The work establishes a clear dramatic situation and an
interesting narrative. Characters are developed fairly completely.
Substantial research has been done and facts are accurate. The
voice is fairly authentic. The point of view is cleverly chosen
to relate the narrative, but may be inconsistent at times. Setting
is generally described to evoke an adequate sense of place. The
writing employs some sensory details and some concrete language.
Few unrelated details and inconsistencies. Dialogue, dramatic
tension, rhythm, figurative language are adequately employed.
The writing addresses, fairly completely, the social, cultural,
historical or political contexts out of which the social action
art emerges. It demonstrates, fairly well, an informed and ethical
reflection of a significant social issue. The work has been presented
to a diverse audience and engaged with the interests and needs
of that audience. Errors in spelling, punctuation, mechanics,
and usage do not impede understanding.
3 . Satisfactory.
The creative non-fiction writing meets most of the criteria stated
above. A basic dramatic situation and narrative exist in the
work. Characters, setting, voice, and point of view are discernible.
Research has been done but facts are occasionally inconsistent.
Occasional sensory details and concrete language exist. Many
unnecessary details and inconsistencies. Dialogue, dramatic tension,
rhythm, and figurative language need further crafting. The writing
is moving toward addressing the social, cultural, historical
or political contexts out of which the social action art emerges.
Some evidence exists of an informed and ethical reflection of
the significant social issue. The writing has been presented
to a diverse audience. Errors in spelling, punctuation, mechanics,
and usage do not impede understanding.
2. Needs Improvement.
The creative non-fiction writing meets some of the criteria stated
above. The work may need a clear dramatic situation and more
adequate narrative. Characters may need more development. The
work may need more research and many facts may need to be reconsidered.
The voice may need more authenticity. The point of view chosen
to relate the story requires consistency. Setting requires more
development. An awareness of sensory details and concrete language
may be necessary. Dialogue, dramatic tension, rhythm, and figurative
language may need work. The writing may need to address the social,
cultural, historical or political contexts out of which the social
action art emerges. The work needs to demonstrate a more informed
and ethical reflection of the significant social issue. The creative
non-fiction writing may need to be presented to a diverse audience.
Errors in spelling, punctuation, mechanics, and usage impede
understanding.
1. Needs Considerable Improvement.
The creative non-fiction writing meets few of the criteria stated
above The characters, narrative, setting, voice, point of view
needs development. The work needs more research and the facts
need to be reconsidered. An awareness of sensory details and
concrete language is necessary. Dialogue, dramatic tension, rhythm,
sensory details, concrete and figurative language needs work.
The writing needs to address the social, cultural, historical
or political contexts out of which the social action art emerges.
The work needs to demonstrate a more informed and ethical reflection
of the significant social issue. The creative non-fiction writing
needs to be presented to a diverse audience. Errors in spelling,
punctuation, mechanics, and usage impede understanding. |